The Best of Mordechai Ben David – a Career Perspective pt. 4

General — By on June 1, 2012 7:00 am

Maaminim: (***) 2001: The title track of this album went just about as far as Moshiach did, becoming the next in MBD’s series of uber-hits, and being sung at soccer games in Yerushalayim. MBD’s voice still sounds strong and powerful, and he really belts it out. I don’t know why they went with the fake horns in the orchestration – the song would not have been the same without the authentic sax, and real brass would have lifted it up even further. Maaminim is followed by another two above-average songs in the beautiful Torah Hakedosha and the electro Lefonov Naavod, but falls to average and below for the rest of the album. Chasoif, the Yiddish song on the record is the one other exception; MBD puts it out with feeling, and the chorus does nothing if not send shivers up your spine. (Hey – am I the only one who thinks that the song Chasoif, put out in memory of the Mumbai massacre by Benny Friedman, etc., is way too similar to this song?) No other song on the album moves me at all.

Kumzits: (***1/2) 2003: A refined sound permeates this live album, with Avi Piamenta’s flute featured prominently. An alternate name could have been “MBD Unplugged”, because that’s the style and attitude, despite the electric guitar that appears on Moshiach and the background keyboards. This is a mellow record that gives new perspective to some oldies, as well as songs that were not originally MBD’s. Yeedle’s hit Shiru Lamelech begins things off, and the guys from Yeshivas Shaarei Yosher seem to really know what they’re doing. Awesome percussion gives the ear pleasure throughout, beginning with the intro to Avraham Fried’s Hinei Ma Tov (actually, a Pittsburgher Niggun). Yaakov Shwekey’s Rachem (#4) is far better than the original, but still, “I’m So Sick of Rachem” and all that… That’s a song that was just overused. Ma Oshiv was a nice addition. After all, it had been originally produced on Suki and Ding’s Hallel, and album that is all but forgotten. The guys really get into it on Carlebach’s Venisgov (#2) and quickly move into his Mizmor Ledovid, sans words. The reprises on the album – Lo Omus, Va’ani Bechasdecha #2, Moshiach and Lulei Soroscha – are all pretty and sweet. This is a really chill album with lots of good stuff.

Nachamu Ami: (*) 2004: With only three songs, and one (Boi Yovoi) that got rereleased on Efshar Letaken, this is a pretty forgettable CD. T he quality of the songs isn’t that bad – they would all be fine as fillers on, say, Efshar Letaken, but as a single, they don’t do justice to each other. Boi Yovoi is the only fast tune, which did not need a child soloist at all. Nachamu Ami is pretty, and Ad Mosai – taking lyrics used earlier in the awesome Al Tisya’esh, but with a tearful expression used here – has the tune of a heartfelt Tefillah, but MBD spends too much time going falsetto. It intrigues me to find out what they were thinking to release these three songs separate from a full album – it just doesn’t make that much sense to me.

Efshar Letaken: (***) 2006: To my mind, this record is a direct continuation in concept and style of Maaminim. It has a few good tunes in Usid and Nodeh Lecho – notable mention goes to the falsetto bridge in the latter song. Veshulmu is another solid, eminently singable song; an obvious Hillel Paley composition. The two best songs on the album, Gevald and Mi Ch’amcha, reflect each other with the Ashkenazic vs. Sefardic expressions (Mi Ch’amcha featuring a very Sephardic, “Wy, wy, wy…”). And the Yeshiva Boys Choir makes a nice guest appearance on Ono Melech, another decent piece. But the album as a whole staggers under the weight of three lesser songs: B’Rosh Hashana (#2) – with its snappy tune no match whatsoever for the somber lyrics. Really, what were they thinking? (Though I must admit that I always liked the shofar there.) Ve’da is an average composition, with a weak arrangement amid weak harmonies, and lyrics that just aren’t balanced well off the tune. Yeedle (the producer) could have found a song that would have fit his talents better. And the title track has a great concept and artsy production, as well as a good chorus, but at over ten minutes (!), especially considering the lengthy Carlebach-like speech, it’s just way too long. As for the rerelease of Boi Yovoi, while it may be better here (it’s faster and peppier), it’s unnecessary.

The Yiddish Collection: (**1/2) 2007: Another anthology, but this one has a very different approach than the one taken for The English Collection. Only six songs here were rerecorded, and only one very weak song (Tatte) is new. While a song as superb as Golus Pharoah did not need to be remixed, Yidden was pretty tired – having appeared on 3 HASCs and Live in Yerushalayim, besides the original. As for the six new oldies, it must be said that it was going to be difficult to repeat his success, simply because competing with his own youth is just impossible; his voice here is thick and heavy, and cannot compare with the light and lithe voice of the originals. If I were involved, I would have taken the vocals from the original and placed them atop the new arrangements. I really like the fact that they took the beautiful old arrangements and gave them slight modern adaptations. Ich Hob Gevart is the top song on the album, followed closely by Tayere Futter. Nix the child soloist on Bloz Dem Shofar, and that would have been a good song. Lichtiger Shabbos should have been slowed down a bit. It’s a nice compilation of songs, but too much to complain about on the redone songs.

The Platinum Collection: 2009: I guess you could say that this is a collection from about when MBD went platinum. I say that, because this collection only takes numbers from The Double Album and onwards – surprisingly not drawing from the powerhouses of the 80’s, Let My People Go and Not For Sale. All in all, if you were going to buy only one album from the 90’s and onwards, this is a decent collection. “Decent” only because there is oh-so-much missing – in this writer’s opinion, it really is worth your while to buy every album! As an album with nothing new and nothing changed, it remains unrated. (There does seem to be a three CD collection from GalPaz called MBD Greatest Hits that includes the king’s earlier albums, but I’m not sure if that’s officially sanctioned, or an Israeli rip-off.)

Kulom Ahuvim: (*****) 2009: It had been a long time since a truly great album had been released by the king, so you’ll have to forgive those of us who had begun to doubt. But we should not have. In Kulom Ahuvim, Mordechai whipped out an excellent selection of songs with aplomb. His voice is better here than it had been in quite a while, and with songs for all tastes, nothing is missing here. Well, maybe an English song would have been nice. But besides that, look what we have here: dance-worthy jumpers in Kulom Ahuvim, Im Ain (#2) and Omar R’ Akiva; absolutely stunning crooners in the gentle Uv’Yerushalayim, Es Achai – with its subtle commentary on the tragic disengagement from Gush Katif – and Im Yihyeh, with a stunning gentle fade-out for a finale; a brilliant track and duet in Aaron Razel’s B’inyan Hasimcha; and solid, above average fillers. The orchestration of Es Achai brings to mind very old memories, being very similar to the accompaniment to Keili Keili #1, from Hineni. The weakest link would be Ki Elokim – a very pretty tune that doesn’t match the lyrics well. If we’re going to nitpick, Omar R’ Akiva is extremely similar in style to the classic tune with those lyrics, sung on the Lag B’omer Medley on Around the Year. The power-laden orchestration, reminiscent of Pulp Fiction’s/Dick Dale’s/Greek traditional (and Mostly Horas’) Misirlou, though, differentiates the two. I get a real kick out of the story told in the Yiddish Moidim Anachni Loch. MBD (via Lipa) says, “Mein kind, di leibst in a tu’ois” – “My child, you’re living in a mistake.” Ya gotta agree with that sentiment when talking about a guy who’s dumb enough to think that he can out-daven the Chofetz Chaim by dragging out his Shmoneh Esrai as long as possible! In any case, the story reveals the extent of the Chafetz Chaim’s Ahavas Yisrael, as he responded to a childish question with an answer that even that guy could understand… But I digress. In short, it’s just another good song on a great album. Now if only they picked up that finale for a continued instrumental…

Kissifim: (***) 2011: Everyone considered this to be a totally unexpected final recording, and based on Wikipedia, maybe it won’t be. Kissifim is an album with a pretty low key presence and a guitar-based sound that harkens back to Kumzits, yet it has an element of charm that is its own. I reviewed the entire album when it came out, and my feelings have largely stood the year since. But in short, I would have liked to here more of MBD and less of the Shira Choir, who got equal billing for some reason, echoing the strong presence of the choir on MBD and Friends. The best songs on the work are Shomrei, the Chabad Anim Zemiros, and yet another gorgeous Yiddish song in the title track. But… one more Ani Maamin (#7!) tucked inside the Werdyger Medley. Although somewhat inexplicable in its execution, this is still a fine and worthy record.

So now we get to what is certain to be disagreed upon by virtually everyone who reads this article – the almost arbitrary awarding of “Best” to four decades of musical artistry: comprising the work of dozens of talented composers, arrangers, musicians and engineers, atop of the voice of Jewish music, Mordechai Ben David.

Top Album: Call this a cop-out, but I can’t decide on an ultimate best album. Instead I’ll go by the decade: the ‘70’s, Hineni; the ‘80’s, Let My People Go (for vocals and arrangement) or Not For Sale (song quality); the ‘90’s, We Are One; the 2000’s, Kulom Ahuvim.

Top Song: Ugh. I can’t get even close to that! I’ll have to divide it into subdivisions:

Top English song: Lyrically, We Are One; Vocally, Let My People Go

Top Ivrit song: Ad Matai, on We Are One.

Top Yiddish song: Golus Pharoah, on Let My People Go

Top fast hit: Daaga Minayin

Top traditional lyrics song: Tov Lehodos, Not for Sale

Top song with lyrics lifted from a Sefer: B’inyan Hasimcha, on Kulom Ahuvim

Top slow song: Ani Maamin, on Let My People Go

Most Overused Lyrics Besides Ani Maamin: Rachem, this is all yours – 4 songs, plus two complete Tzur Mishelos and one incomplete Tzur Mishelo on Around the Year!

Number of Songs that Repeat the Word Shabbos Endlessly: 6 (Ani Shabbos, Yismechu #2, Shabbos Kodesh, Ono Melech, Shomrei, and Yeedle’s Vezakeinu). Did I miss any?

(Part 1 of this series is here, Part 2 here, and Part 3 here.)

Facebook comments:

21 Comments

  1. mbdfan says:

    hey what you think of the song on his newest album – nichsefo? i love that song :)

  2. Hislahavus says:

    It’s a nice song; personally, I don’t think it’s the best on the album though – I’d reserve that for Shomrei or Anim Zemiros. However, MBD sounds great on it, so I understand why you like it.

  3. megaMBDfan says:

    “B’Rosh Hashana (#2) – with its snappy tune no match whatsoever for the somber lyrics. Really, what were they thinking?”

    I hear your point but Efshar Letaken song/album is based on the message of Reb Nachman Breslover zy”a’s vort, אם אתה מאמין שיכולים לקלקל תאמין שיכולים לתקן, That it’s never too late to correct to correct your wrongdoings, and just like you were able to “sabotage” or “ruin” so too can youy correct, the gates of heaven are always open to Tshuvah & Breslovers clap all througout Rosh Hashana & Yom kippur davening!

    Btw, I would appreciate if you can reply regarding my #7 comment on MBD,Retrospective pt.3 Thanks!

  4. Hislahavus says:

    Fair enough – reminds me of the Baal Shem Tov’s chossid who would sing a joyous tune during Ashamnu. People complained to the Besht, who called him in and asked him about it. The chosid answered, “People sing when cleaning their homes, should I not sing when cleaning myself?”

    As for your other comment, I don’t have anything to say about it. Your point is taken…

  5. JtopBlogger says:

    Nice job. can you do one on Avraham Fried?

  6. Hislahavus says:

    Thanks! I did one a long time ago, which is here: http://jewishmusicreport.com/2009/03/20/best-of-avraham-fried/
    However, I think it needs a redo. I hope to rewrite it sometime soon; however, as with the MBD albums, I need to acquire a few more albums before I do it. Here are three more of the series:
    Piamenta: http://jewishmusicreport.com/2009/02/20/best-of-the-piamentas/
    Abie Rotenberg: http://jewishmusicreport.com/2009/04/20/best-of-abie-rotenberg/
    Tzlil V’zemer: http://jewishmusicreport.com/2009/04/20/best-of-tzlil-vzemer/

  7. mbdfan says:

    @hishlavus maybe you can do a long rant column at `the powers that be` for not bringing out many hasc videos before 2004, and denying the olom of so many wonderful moment

  8. music says:

    im sory but ephshar ltaken is five star

  9. Hislahavus says:

    You’re welcome to disagree with me, but PLEASE explain yourselves! Dissect my review – go ahead!

  10. Meir says:

    Hislahavus,

    I have to disagree with you on Efshar L’taken. From the first time I listened to it I have loved the progression of the song and how it relates to the lyrics. The length of the song is related to the need for the hope MBD refers to to build up to the final realization that everything will work out for the best. (That was a really long sentence but I think it makes sense.)

    Also, as far as the talking type low part, to me it just means that MBD’s voice was so full and rich that by simply talking he can communicate the dispair he is refering to.

    That said I hear where you are coming from and understand why many people do not like that particular song.

    Meir

  11. Hislahavus says:

    Ah, R’ Meir, I was wondering when we’d see you! I get your what you’re saying, but the song is still 9 minutes long! Do you listen to it fully every time you hear it, or do you hit skip?

    And, of course, I hope you’ll continue the conversation further – I’m sure you disagree with more in this series than just this one song. :-) Your comments always cause me to reflect and listen again, and I appreciate that.

  12. Meir says:

    Hislahavus,

    Truthfully I rarely listen to it at all. When I do it’s because I need the message and yes, I listen to it all.

    Sorry for not being more active throughout this series, I’ve been crazy busy. Moving, starting grad school etc… As soon as things get a little normal I’ll read through them like a mentch and see if I have anything more to add.

    Meir

  13. Hislahavus says:

    :-) Well, in that case, good luck with all the movement in your life – meshaneh mokom, meshaneh mazel letovah, and we’re looking forward to hearing more from you.

  14. megaMBDfan says:

    Hislahavus,

    You know what amazes me, Certain songs from mbd albums where he re-sings them live @ a concert like Hasc, Ohel, Live In Jerusalem, Etc, Has a huge difference to the better!

    Some Examples: 1) Racheim Bechasdecha (originally, just one shabbos) re-sung @ Live In Jerusalem way better than the original! – as you mentioned! –

    2) Mimkomcha, – I as well have no clue about the originality of the song – (originally so to speak, SOLID MBD) re-sung @ Hasc 7 where its expressed with such beauty & power that one might think it 2 separate songs!

    3) Ko Amar (originally, Yerushalayim our home) re-sung @ Hasc 6 with so much more oomph, twists & “hartz”!

    4) Kol Dodi (actually his first time presenting this song here) & Someday we will all be together, @ Ohel Concert 5758 is another 2 classics which he sings best LIVE on stage! (Just expressing my opinions :-)

    Btw, You did a superb job writing up these reviews on all his official albums, I can only imagine the time & effort that comes along. I hope the readers appreciates that, even if opinions aren’t agreed upon always. Good Luck! Sruly

  15. Hislahavus says:

    Thanks, Sruly! Yeah, it took quite a bit of my free time, so I appreciate your comments.

    Re your thoughts, I agree with you. Live oftentimes adds to the experience with the raw energy that a studio rarely matches. Along with that are the occasional mistakes that can happen on stage as well, so it’s a give and take situation. But all the songs you mentioned are certainly worthy live productions. I agree with you on all accounts. :-)

  16. Shim says:

    Well done for a great 4 piece article, although as a hardcore MBD fan may I humbly point out a few chashuva nekudos.
    1. Yeedle on his album Lev Echad redoes Min Hameitzar from MBD live 1981. MBD sings on there too. An old song brought back to life with beautiful arrangements. Well worth a listen.
    2. You gave The Double Album 4 stars?!?!? Undoubtably in the top 3 MBD albums of all time…
    3. Moshiach 3 STARS?!?!? You deserve all the flack you get for that, my friend. The rest of the album is far from average.You call Crack Of Dawn ‘ok’?? A deep message lies in that song, besides for excellent arrangements and the changing of tempo in the middle to fit with the lyrics..Shema Beni – a classic, sung again and again at many concerts. And what is wrong with re – using lyrics? The Ani Ma’amin happens to be in my top 3 slow MBD’s, a song that has been sung at many Kumzitz’s on many occasions…and no mention at all of Ko Ribon, a genius composition and a regular at my Shabbos table on Friday nights…
    4. Ein Od Milvado – another top album that you fail to give sufficient credit for. Every single song has perfect arrangements, outstanding vocals and choir on every single track. Not quite sure what you were thinking with the 3 stars.
    5. Maaminim – A great album all round that also only deserves 3 stars. “but falls to average and below for the rest of the album…” No mention of Shir Chodosh, an excellent song, Midas Horachamim – a gorgeous, soul stirring piece, or Veyishoma – a great chasunah song! Another excellent album in my opinion…
    6. And if you are still reading this, your ‘Best’ section requires a few urgent and neccessary changes so that it is a true and accurate reflection on the King Of Jewish Music.

    The Top album from the 90’s is Moshiach. Nothing really to discuss there.
    Top English song: Lyrically, Unity from The English Collection; Vocally, Let My People Go (agreed!)
    Top Ivrit song: Kochavim, from MBD 25 Years. (Originally on Neshama) The way he expresses the lyrics whilst singing is truly unbelievable.
    Top Yiddish song: Golus Pharoah, on Let My People Go (Bang on!Was always my #1 favourite, although Mi Ke’amcho Yisroel is not far behind…)
    Top fast hit: Has got to be Ma’aminim, sung all over the world…
    Top traditional lyrics song: Perok from Just One Shabbos
    Top song with lyrics lifted from a Sefer: Al Kol Rega Vorega
    Top slow song: My top 4, not in order – Hakshiva, Od Yeishvu, Ani Maa’min from Moshiach and Vehochein Parnososeinu

  17. Hislahavus says:

    Good and fun comment, Shim! While I stick with my picks and opinion, the only thing I strongly disagree with you is Kochavim/Shir Shem Shalom. I’ve never heard the version on 25 Years – is it any different than the original? Whatever the case, c’mon – a. It’s a stolen tune; b. the lyrics are SO naive! But besides that, even if we disagree, I hear where you’re coming from. I still think you’re underrating We Are One as a total album, though.

  18. Shim says:

    I hear what you are saying, although at the end of the day its all a matter of opinion…lets agree to disagree ok? :-) Kudos for a great article!

  19. Question says:

    In my computer collection I have some unidentified albums, can you help?

    One album called “Little Neshomole” (which the first half is songs from the double album #2) and the second half i can’t figure out.

    One album is called “Live in Brooklyn College”

    One is “Live In Argentina”

    and one is “Zichronus” which is different than “memories”

  20. Hislahavus says:

    I’d need more info, but are these all MBD albums? They’re certainly mislabeled. Live in Argentina sounds like a Yehuda Glantz album.

  21. larry says:

    Top Album: the ‘70’s, Hineni; the ‘80’s, Let My People Go; the ‘90’s, Moshiach; the 2000’s, Efshar Letaken.

Leave a Comment